Managing People

Lesson 6 · People

Performance management

Diagnose before you prescribe. Most underperformance is not a motivation problem.

Performance management is mostly not about reviews. It is the continuous loop of setting clear expectations, observing, giving feedback and adjusting; the periodic review only summarizes it. If expectations were never explicit, you cannot fairly call someone an underperformer.

When someone is struggling, diagnose before you prescribe. Is it clarity (they do not know what good looks like), capability (they lack a skill), motivation (they can but do not want to), or environment (something outside their control is in the way)? Each has a different fix: clarify, train, understand or unblock. Managers tend to assume motivation. It is more often clarity.

If the gap persists after clear feedback and real support, act: a written plan with specific, measurable expectations, a time frame, and a genuine decision at the end. Avoiding this is unfair to the person and to the team — your strongest people notice what is tolerated. Calibration, where managers compare ratings together, keeps the bar consistent and counters leniency and recency bias.

Picture it

Tomás's pull requests are slow and thin, and his manager assumes he is coasting. In their one-on-one she asks instead of tells, and learns that another team has been pulling him into support escalations four hours a day. That is environment, not motivation. She gets the escalations routed properly and his output recovers within two weeks. A performance plan would have lost a good engineer.

Key formulas & frameworks

The loop
Set expectations → Observe → Give feedback → Adjust
Diagnosing underperformance
Clarity · Capability · Motivation · Environment
Performance plan
Specific expectations + Support + Time frame + Decision
Calibration
Managers compare ratings to hold one consistent bar

Practice

Score: 0 / 5

Question 1

Q1.An engineer keeps missing deadlines. It turns out nobody told them which of their four projects mattered most. What is the root cause?

Question 2

Q2.The annual review is the main mechanism of performance management.

Question 3

Q3.A strong backend engineer is struggling with their first infrastructure tasks. What is the most fitting response?

Question 4

Q4.What is calibration for?

Question 5

Q5.Tolerating sustained underperformance affects the motivation of the team's strongest performers.

Up nextMotivation & retention

Next lesson